Fitzwilliam Darcy
GENTLEMAN
Book II
Duty and Desire
by Pamela Aidan

 
Duty
Paperback -  320  pages - (October 3 2006) 
Touchstone; ISBN 0743291360
amazon.com
amazon.co.uk
amazon.ca


         Written by Karen 2L (9/20/2004 12:26 p.m.)

The writing is as good -- and far fewer typos and wierd grammar gremlins. One thing I can't figure out -- the Colonel's elder brother's first name is D'Arcy. So would the inference be that the Colonel is related to Darcy on both Darcy's mother's and father's side? Odd...

The story is mostly new since it follows Darcy from leaving Netherfield to getting ready for Rosings -- a period of time that JA never touches. I found this story a bit on the "Udolpho" side.

All in all, a wonderful read, and just makes you yearn even more for These Three Remain.


        Written by Kathi (2/13/2005 9:06 p.m.)
However, I found _Duty and Desire_ a great disappointment and only bothered to plow through it because I thought it might be necessary to understanding the third book. Having finished it, I wish I had just skipped it. It has very little to do with anything in P&P; as someone else has pointed out, is more Radcliffe than Austen; and it was fairly boring. It was difficult to keep the new characters straight, and I didn't care enough about them to try very hard. I'll probably read the third one, though, because I assume it will return to Austen.


         Written by Sarah Catherine  (2/18/2005 10:58 p.m.) Then I got to Duty and Desire and, though it was entertaining, kept saying "What? Voodoo? Spells? What? Kidnapped baby? Not really dead stepmother? What novel am I in again?" As Henry Tilney would say, it all sounded like something out of Mrs. Radcliffe. I think that the author, when focusing on a period during which Darcy is out of contact with Elizabeth and for which there's no guidance from P&P, got a bit carried away and let the novel write her.


        Written by Kathleen Glancy  (6/6/2005 5:35 p.m.)
It seems like more of an alternative viewpoint than a sequel, a popular area. There's the Fitzwilliam Darcy, Gentleman trilogy of which I liked the first book and was disappointed in the second, but have great hopes of the the yet unpublished third.


          Written by Sharondio (February 13, 2007 )
I read it and was disappointed. But then I realized that the reason I didn't love it was that it *was* a major departure from the storyline I was expecting. Once I decided to try to appreciate it as a book that could stand on its own, it improved very much. It also shows great promise for more books from Pamela.
        Written by RuthO (4/2/2007 1:09 p.m.)
You can skip the second book in the Triology without missing any of JA's plot. The first book ends after the Bingleys leave Netherfield, the third book picks up on the way to Hunsford. The second book tells a story of Mr. Darcy solving a murder mystery involving some Irish rebels and has nothing to do with the Plot of P&P. The rebels make a return appearance in the third book, but it is happly a short appearance.

        Written by Kara M (3/26/2007 5:04 p.m.)
I found the second volume silly and ridiculous. Over all, though, I enjoyed reading it.

        Written by Lele (3/26/2007 5:26 p.m.)
My favorite by far is Pamela Aidan's trilogy! I think she stays true to JA's Darcy and also introduces wonderful new characters. I actually enjoyed all three books. The second was quite different from the other two, but still a fun read. I can't wait to read more from her.