Huh?
Posted by Emmy on February 25, 1998 at 00:45:48:
In response to Elinor, written by Bonny on February 24, 1998 at 03:29:50
Elinors 19. Personally, though, I wouldn't exchange them. I like the casting of S&S 2 as it is! ;-)
19, I didn't think she was that young, but it's been a while since I read it. Still, I always thought that she was 23ish. I agree with you about the casting. KW just is Marianne, there is no question. Kinda like Megan Follows is the only person who could ever play Anne Shirley. IMHO of course
Em
- And I agree with you Bonny 04:32:57 2/28/98
(9)
- I never thought of that Emmy 17:09:10 2/28/98
(6)
- You're right Bonny 04:01:08 3/02/98
(5)
- Maybe it's because I read it when i was 8, but... Emmy 18:44:40 3/04/98
(4)
- I know Bonny 06:05:18 3/05/98
(3)
- Great!! Emmy 20:12:18 3/06/98
(2)
- Emmy, I e-mailed you.:-) Post me if you didn't recieve it.(nfm) Bonny 05:09:19 3/12/98
(0)
- Emmy, I e-mailed you.:-) Post me if you didn't recieve it.(nfm) Bonny 05:09:14 3/12/98
(0)
- Emmy, I e-mailed you.:-) Post me if you didn't recieve it.(nfm) Bonny 05:09:19 3/12/98
(0)
- Great!! Emmy 20:12:18 3/06/98
(2)
- I know Bonny 06:05:18 3/05/98
(3)
- Maybe it's because I read it when i was 8, but... Emmy 18:44:40 3/04/98
(4)
- You're right Bonny 04:01:08 3/02/98
(5)
- Marianne's motivation Shirley 14:38:26 2/28/98
(1)
- Yes Bonny 04:36:58 3/02/98
(0)
- Yes Bonny 04:36:58 3/02/98
(0)
- I never thought of that Emmy 17:09:10 2/28/98
(6)
- Right age. Kathleen Ann 10:45:01 2/25/98
(0)
- Elinor's age Linda 09:25:10 2/25/98
(3)
- really Emmy 23:02:47 2/25/98
(2)
- Ooops! Linda 08:51:05 2/26/98
(1)
- Don't worry Emmy 21:46:03 2/26/98
(0)
- Don't worry Emmy 21:46:03 2/26/98
(0)
- Ooops! Linda 08:51:05 2/26/98
(1)
- really Emmy 23:02:47 2/25/98
(2)
Posting followups to old messages is disabled; instead go to the main index and post a new message which mentions this one.
