Would you believe it?

Posted by Constanza on December 05, 1997 at 15:14:42:

Jane Eyre has just been released in Buenos Aires and would you believe what one critic said about it! That it was a good film but... the plot was old fashioned, the novel wouldn't stand the passage of time, it was too melodramatic... ie, the director, the actors, all did their best, but the script was based on a book that was considered good last century but may not longer though of as such now in the XX century!!! How does he dare?

REPLIES:

• on the other hand.... Kathleen T 14:05:48 12/08/97 (3)
  • Jane Eyre, Rebecca and the Spice Girls. Rissie 15:08:01 12/12/97 (2)
    • Well, I confess to liking Rebecca, and Jamaica Inn to boot! nfm Constanza 15:56:36 12/12/97 (1)
      • And how about the Spice Girls? ; ) NFM Rissie 17:00:53 12/12/97 (0)
• Critique of critics gkb 22:21:54 12/07/97 (1)
  • Absolutely! Hitting that nail square on the head... ;-) (NFM) SaraDJ 23:24:31 12/07/97 (0)
• Oh, gee . . . SaraDJ 10:10:03 12/06/97 (0)
• Product of.... Leigh 15:51:48 12/05/97 (1)
  • of...inbreeding?(nfm) ;-p AnneM 20:25:33 12/05/97 (0)

Posting followups to old messages is disabled; instead go to the main index and post a new message which mentions this one.