Posted by Linda K. on June 30, 1997 at 22:04:51:
In reply to Re: Emma3 posted by Kathy F. on June 28, 1997 at 19:53:15
] I'm planning on watching Emma2 sometime to re-evaluate the constant praise on this board, but I didn't like it nearly as well as Emma3. Depressing??? It was funny!
Ditto! I enjoyed Emma3 far more than Emma2 and much preferred KB's & MS's portral of the characters. The two adaptations emphasized different parts of the novel, and I did sometimes prefer the inclusion of a particular scene in Emma2 that was missing in Emma3, but on the whole there is no comparison for me - Emma3 truly stands out in my mind.
] Now, as to the performances of KB and MS, I'm speechless. I didn't find her stiff at all, and he was far from annoying..
Double Ditto!! Nothing stiff about KB in this performance, and MS annoying?? Nevah!
] I guess I ought to conclude by saying--give Emma3 another chance. I'm going to give Emma2 another chance.
] Kathy :-)
I believe I will give Emma2 another chance just for fun, but I doubt that I will be very much swayed! ;-)