Quick Index Board Index Home FAQ Site Map

View thread | Previous message | Next message


GR Some Closing Thoughts and Comments   Written by BarbaraB (9/20/2003 6:09 a.m.)
Are you new?

*PARALLELS I didn't get to explore in the kind of depth that I would have liked with the parallels but a couple more interesting things:


1. The narrator says of John Dashwood that " he was not an ill-disposed young man, unless to be rather cold-hearted, and rather selfish is to be ill disposed:" and Elinor thinks about Willoughby in these terms: "Extravagance and vanity had made him cold-hearted and selfish." [Bold Mine]
2. "Lucy's calculating approach to life and her prohibited love affair with Edward caricature Elinor's, and the passionate love that nearly destroys Marianne is elaborately parodied by the story or the two Elizas that Colonel Brandon tells. The details of that story--a callous parent committed to primogeniture, brothers at odds with one one another, two women's lives irrecoverably lost--echo the novel's plots and its themes of selfishness and greed." (Cambridge Companion) I haven't had much chance to digest this very much but I thought I'd share it. It's was something to think about.

*THE GROOMS In my estimation the Colonel and Edward are both honorable and good men though I think the Col. is a far superior character. Edward's flaws and errors are fairly obvious. The Colonel has two things that I can think of offhand that might be considered as flaws. The first is that he has allowed the past events with Eliza to impact his life for too long a time. It has ruined what was apparently a naturally lively nature and kept certain feelings on hold for years. He is very eligible and if he had been open to the notion of someday meeting someone there is a good chance that he would have met a woman worthy of him long before now. It is something he didn't seem to even want to consider. Until Marianne comes on the scene and jolts him out of his disallusionment with her similarities to Eliza he seemed 'happy' to live with the status quo. The other thing is--well, I want to say he should have informed the Dashwoods of Willoughby's character after the duel though I'm having a hard time convincing myself of this entirely. I realize he loved Marianne so much he wanted to see her happy. But after Willoughby's dispicable behavior has been so well detailed, I can't see that he would have been doing her any favors. It would have been kind of like letting her walk into a lion's den. Then I wondered how he would go about it such a thing. It would seem that the proper way to handle it would be to inform a male member of the family who would then relay the information to the ladies who could then determine their actions. Ok, I then realized that the only two male members were John Dashwood and Sir John. The Colonel would be imparting private/delicate information relating to himself as well. He didn't know JD (and if he did...) and though Sir John was a good friend, he lacked decorum. So I could see how he'd be reluctant and sympathize with the position in which he found himself. Still... Hmmmm, a tough call, indeed.

*ENDING/REWRITING JA I can't help wishing the ending could have been fleshed out a bit more. I think some of the criticism we read about is often a result of the fact that it is wrapped up so quickly. The age factor isn't a problem for me but if we could have seen the courtship between CB and Marianne it I think it would have worked better. The movie plays better because we do get to see a small part of the courtship. Nevertheless, chagrin and all (see below), I do love reading the final chapter, getting all the loose ends tied up and seeing the Dashwoods ladies settled into their marriages with decent men.
At the beginning of the GR I quoted a passage. I was fascinated by it but held off commenting on it because I wanted to see if/how it would hold up. "The narrator's tone implies it is as certain as death that men merely use dependent women, that virtue goes unrewarded, that ingratitude, caprice and selfishness prevail, that people do active harm and yet remain respectable." (Cambridge Companion) Unfortunately, it seems that it does hold up. Every time I get to the end of this book I come to what I call 'The Bad Guys Making Out Like Bandits'.
I always heartily wish that Willoughby's wife would plague his heart out and that the John Dashwoods and the Robert Farrares would, through some bad financial planning or decisions or investments, fall on hard times. I know, I know, there's a point to be made. In fact, many selfish and greedy people get to live out their greedy lives in financial splendor. JA does hint that their lives are not perfect though. Willoughby is not entirely happy with his wife. Indeed, she sounds a bit shrewish. Robert and Lucy argue a lot (hee hee) and the ever greedy Dashwoods, always wanting more money, could never truly be happy with what they have since it's never enough. Still they all get off better than they ought.
Do men merely use dependent women? In a lot of instances, yes. Character after character has done just that marrying them for their money and little else.
As for Elinor and Marinnne, they get their 'happily ever afters', especially Elinor who gets her first love as reward for her exceptional character, perception and good sense while mostly everyone else ends up with a second attachment (which was a good thing for some). May all these JA characters get out of their marriages what they deserve. ;-)


Previous message | Next message | Board index

All messages in the thread


Password:

Sense & Sensibility is maintained by Barbara with WebBBS 3.21.


View thread | Previous message | Next message
Board index

Group Read Board Pride & Prejudice Board Emma Board Sense & Sensibility Board Persuasion Board Mansfield Park Board Northanger Abbey Board Austenuations Board Jane Austen's Life & Times Board Lady Catherine & Co. Board Library Board Virtual Views Board Ramble Board Meetings Board Newcomers' Board Milestones Board Help Board Pemberleans Board





- Jane Austen | Republic of Pemberley -

Quick Index Home Site Map JAInfo

© 2004 - 2012 The Republic of Pemberley

Get copyright permissions

Quantcast