Quick Index Board Index Home FAQ Site Map

View thread Post response Board index Previous message Next message


Duel   Written by Kristina F (2/21/2013 12:47 a.m.) in consequence of the missive, Brandon versus Brandon, penned by Robbin
Are you new?

In the novel Col Brandon does not act like this and he does not seem angry until he confesses to Elinor. How do you think the countenance and behavior of S&S3’s Brandon compares to the Original?

I agree with you that Austen's Col. Brandon hides (or controls) his anger quite a bit better than S&S3's Brandon, and I also admit that asking Willoughby what his intentions are toward Marianne certainly isn't in the novel, and in fact makes Brandon appear more confrontational than he should.

However, it should be noted that Brandon in S&S3 has a fair opportunity to kill or seriously maim Willoughby in the duel, and he chooses to spare him. In the book, I have always assumed that Brandon fully intended to kill Willoughby if he could, and was only prevented from doing so due to the inaccuracy of Regency era pistols and the code of honor that would have to be obeyed during the duel. What I gather from the original S&S2 screenplay is that Emma Thompson probably had this exact same opinion about the duel, so the original intent for S&S2 must have been to have Brandon going into the duel with the intention to kill Willoughby, whereas S&S3 clearly indicates that Brandon only meant to humiliate him, and so had no intention of doing anything more than giving him a minor wound.

I feel I should point out that I have nothing against Thompson's interpretation of the duel (which did not make the final cut, unfortunately), because I think it is actually a good deal closer to the book than Andrew Davies's interpretation, but, sorry, it just DOES seem more aggressive and violent-minded for Brandon to want Willoughby dead.


Previous message Next message Board index

All messages in the thread


Previous message Next message Board index

Pop up the novel text
Post a Response

Your Name:

OOPS INSURANCE
Put in a password in case you want to delete your message later

E-Mail (Optional; be aware that we've had trouble with people harvesting our addresses):

Subject:

Message:

The youngest sister is _____ Dashwood

Frequently used phrase:

If you want to include a link, please provide both the URL address and a description of the page (start with http:// -- copy the address from your browser to ensure accuracy):

Optional Link URL:

Optional Link Title:



If you'd like to include an image (picture) with your message, please provide the full URL, beginning with http://, of the image file, ending in .jpg or .gif:

Optional Image URL:





Password:

Sense & Sensibility is maintained by Barbara with WebBBS 3.21.


View thread Post response Board index Previous message Next message
Board index

Group Read Board Pride & Prejudice Board Emma Board Sense & Sensibility Board Persuasion Board Mansfield Park Board Northanger Abbey Board Austenuations Board Jane Austen's Life & Times Board Lady Catherine & Co. Board Library Board Virtual Views Board Ramble Board Meetings Board Newcomers' Board Milestones Board Help Board Pemberleans Board





- Jane Austen | Republic of Pemberley -

Quick Index Home Site Map JAInfo

© 2004 - 2012 The Republic of Pemberley

Get copyright permissions

Quantcast