Quick Index Board Index Home FAQ Site Map

View thread Post response Board index Previous message Next message


I must take a very strong stand...   Written by Kristina F (2/16/2013 4:28 p.m.) in consequence of the missive, Showing relationships by symbols and dialog, penned by Robbin
Are you new?

...against your description of S&S3's Colonel Brandon as a "bristling angry man." I do not see this at all, and I think if you watch the scenes with him gently encouraging Marianne in her efforts to learn a challenging piece of music (which he generously gave her) and the tender scene at Eliza's bedside in which he reassures her that she will want for nothing, you will understand why I disagree with your assessment. There are many other tender moments with him in addition to the ones I described. Actually, one of the reasons I dislike what was done with Brandon's character in S&S2 is that he does NOT show any particular affection for or tenderness toward his ward, Eliza. He coldly refers to her as "headstrong" and an "illegitimate child"; if he is supposed to be a caring guardian, then this isn't made clear to the audience. There is a scene in the original S&S2 screenplay with him finding Eliza, expressing shock over her pregnancy, and comforting her. This scene should have been left in the film, IMO, as it would have been the only scene to show any sort of fatherly love from Brandon to Eliza.

Additionally, I don't really agree that the ripe fruit at Delaford in S&S3 is meant to symbolize Marianne's readiness for a romantic and sexual relationship with Brandon. I do agree that the fruit is meant to be symbolic, but I think that another equally valid interpretation could be that it symbolizes Brandon's ability to provide for Marianne and be a good husband. Contrast Brandon's ripe, appetizing, plentiful fruit with Willoughby's paltry offering of wild strawberries earlier in the adaptation; Willoughby's strawberries are small, will not last long, and cannot be gathered over and over again indefinitely, whereas Brandon's fruits from Delaford have been carefully tended to, and as long as the plants continue to be nurtured, they will always bear fruit.


Previous message Next message Board index

All messages in the thread


Previous message Next message Board index

Pop up the novel text
Post a Response

Your Name:

OOPS INSURANCE
Put in a password in case you want to delete your message later

E-Mail (Optional; be aware that we've had trouble with people harvesting our addresses):

Subject:

Message:

Marianne Dashwood is infatuated with John _____

Frequently used phrase:

If you want to include a link, please provide both the URL address and a description of the page (start with http:// -- copy the address from your browser to ensure accuracy):

Optional Link URL:

Optional Link Title:



If you'd like to include an image (picture) with your message, please provide the full URL, beginning with http://, of the image file, ending in .jpg or .gif:

Optional Image URL:





Password:

Sense & Sensibility is maintained by Barbara with WebBBS 3.21.


View thread Post response Board index Previous message Next message
Board index

Group Read Board Pride & Prejudice Board Emma Board Sense & Sensibility Board Persuasion Board Mansfield Park Board Northanger Abbey Board Austenuations Board Jane Austen's Life & Times Board Lady Catherine & Co. Board Library Board Virtual Views Board Ramble Board Meetings Board Newcomers' Board Milestones Board Help Board Pemberleans Board





- Jane Austen | Republic of Pemberley -

Quick Index Home Site Map JAInfo

© 2004 - 2012 The Republic of Pemberley

Get copyright permissions

Quantcast