as negatively as others seem to view her. I've listened intently to the very valid arguments that so many of you have against her, but I just can't judge her so harshly.

Perhaps this is because I am easily guided by the narrator and by Anne's point of view. I cannot escape the impression that JA intended us to view LR as flawed, but good at heart. Perhaps it is because I am the mother of a beautiful, naive, almost 15-year old daughter, and I would be horrified if a charasmatic, impetuous, impulsive, penniless man came to steal her heart with fairy tale promises!

Likewise Mrs. Smith. Yes, her actions are rather troubling, but I still believe JA intended us to see her as really caring about Anne.