Quick Index
Board Index
Home
FAQ
Site Map
Oh, for Pete's sake
Written by Anselm
(4/14/2010 5:32 a.m.)
in consequence of the missive, It was not raining when Jane left., penned by Adrian
Having thus acquitted the lovely Elizabeth of any insensitivity towards the health of her sister, however, I'm still left with her parents' equivalent attitude when they find out what has happened. I can't see how Mr Bennet's reference to the possibility of Jane's developing a serious fit of illness, or even of dying, can not be based on some kind of commonly held expectation that that possibility is a realistic one. The comment wouldn't work otherwise. So we have Jane's father using the prospect of his daughter's impending demise only as the occasion of a jibe at his wife. Thanks, dad - that's thoughtful of you! Her mother then replies, dismissing the suggestion of someone's dying merely as a result of catching a cold. As I've pointed out, Marianne Dashwood nearly dies from one, and Tom Bertram in MP is also in danger of his life from a similarly trivial cause. These again must be based on outcomes that were realistic in 1800. It seems that Mrs Bennet is determined to get Jane together with Bingley, and simply ignores any risk involved, even when it begins to eventuate - i.e. when Jane in fact becomes ill. So I must conclude that both the Bennet parents are quite thoughtless and heartless. |

Groupread is maintained by Myretta with WebBBS 3.21.
