Quick Index Board Index Home FAQ Site Map

View thread | Previous message | Next message


History Repeats Itself   Written by Robbin (10/22/2010 12:21 p.m.) in consequence of the missive, Erasing, penned by Barb JA
Are you new?

I am reconsidering the promotion/proposal combo link per your comments. I am not inclined to say Henry was acting or lying about the receipt of the letters. He was waiting “for very little more than opportunity” (30) and ‘very little more’ could suggest he was waiting for confirmation of the promotion before proposing. It does not seem to me Henry feared William’s promotion would not happen rather it seems he was impatient of the difficulties which prevented it being finished on his time-table:

I will not attempt to describe; how severely mortified, how cruelly disappointed, in not having it finished while I was in London! …But though my uncle entered into my wishes with all the warmth I could desire, and exerted himself immediately, there were difficulties from the absence of one friend, and the engagements of another, which at last I could no longer bear to stay the end of… I came away on Monday, trusting that many posts would not pass before I should be followed by such very letters as these. (31)

Henry called ‘at an earlier hour than common visiting warrants’ (31) because he received the letters confirming the promotion. It was luck that the first opportunity to be alone with Fanny presented at that moment but I have to ask why Henry could hardly bear anyone else share with Fanny the “first knowledge” (31) of William’s promotion:

Henry, overjoyed to have her go, bowed and watched her off, and without losing another moment, turned instantly to Fanny, and, taking out some letters, said, with a most animated look, “I must acknowledge myself infinitely obliged to any creature who gives me such an opportunity of seeing you alone: I have been wishing it more than you can have any idea. Knowing as I do what your feelings as a sister are, I could hardly have borne that any one in the house should share with you in the first knowledge of the news I now bring.” (31)

Is having Fanny alone to announce the promotion to benefit him in some measure or is it only to increase Fanny’s happiness? Could he think Fanny would be less happy to hear the news with other people in the room? I don’t think so—after thanking Henry the first thing she wishes to do is tell Sir Thomas. However Henry could expect the same benefit from being the bearer of such news as he did when he wanted to give her the first knowledge of the Antwerp’s return. I don’t think Henry would fail to consider the effect of announcing the promotion as a past similar announcement had some success:

He proved, however, to be too late. All those fine first feelings, of which he had hoped to be the exciter, were already given. But his intention, the kindness of his intention, was thankfully acknowledged: quite thankfully and warmly, for she was elevated beyond the common timidity of her mind by the flow of her love for William. (24)

Thanks for the kind words Barb JA, I enjoy out discussion as well and I am glad we usually agree however I do not see where I have been contradictory in the statements you quoted. Perhaps the problem is my explanations of intent and method are too muddled. I do not automatically consider the generosity of the promotion erased because I do not think Henry sought it with the vicious self-interest of a cad. I feel Henry was seeking the promotion as part of his quest to marry Fanny or said another way with the self-interest of marital bliss—which I did say for me does not automatically erase generosity. That was intent, now for method. I feel Henry’s use of kindnesses to William, including the promotion, was an unfair method to gain Fanny’s regard and he used it when his intent was idle and when it was honorable thus it is not a banner for bad intent but rather a banner for the shallowness of his character. Anyway, all I want by this explanation is to resolve the appearance of being contradictory and I hope this makes my view clearer. Thanks for reading. (:D)


Previous message | Next message | Board index

All messages in the thread


Password:

Groupread is maintained by Myretta with WebBBS 3.21.


View thread | Previous message | Next message
Board index

Group Read Board Pride & Prejudice Board Emma Board Sense & Sensibility Board Persuasion Board Mansfield Park Board Northanger Abbey Board Austenuations Board Jane Austen's Life & Times Board Lady Catherine & Co. Board Library Board Virtual Views Board Ramble Board Meetings Board Newcomers' Board Milestones Board Help Board Pemberleans Board





- Jane Austen | Republic of Pemberley -

Quick Index Home Site Map JAInfo

© 2004 - 2012 The Republic of Pemberley

Get copyright permissions

Quantcast