I have seen the MP1 adaptation, and MP3 adaptation. The horror stories I've heard about the revisionist MP2 adaptation kept me from wasting my time with it. I wish I hadn't bothered with MP3, which was also revisionist, in my mind, at least -- BILLIE PIPER?!! (Whose idea was THAT?!)

I liked the "One" version, but it was a few years ago, and not reading JA's book makes a big difference in anyone's attitude to any of her stories. I knew the GR would be coming, so here I am. I enjoy the GR's, for the same reasons given by Patricia AA, and Angela L. I get much more from sharing the novels with others more knowledgeable than I am, thank you all very much!