This scene made me think again about Mr John Knightley. Primed by his many admirers here, I was liking him very much until this. But the contrast with his brother's actions pulled me up short. Why does Mr John Knightley take such pleasure in winding up his father in law like this? It seems quite cruel really. I may be a bit touchy as I have a brother who I could imagine acting like this, and it annoys me intensely.

On the other hand, my feelings towards Emma were improved by her sensible response and the skill with which she manages her father and sister. And yes, the rapport between Emma and Mr Knightley is very real in this exchange.